This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Free Shipping on Retail Orders Greater than $75!*

Heat sensitive items require expedited shipping fees.

The Penny Candy Store The Penny Candy Store

Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

NEWLY ADDED ITEMS

Home/Collections/NEWLY ADDED ITEMS
Quick View

SOUR SKITTLES POP'D FREEZE DRIED CANDY

$9.99

Quick View

JOLLY RANCHER GUMMIES SOUR 6.5 OZ PEG BAG

$3.50

Quick View

MIKE AND IKE BERRY BLAST

From $0.33

Quick View

MIKE AND IKE JOLLY JOES THEATER BOX

$1.95

Quick View

REED'S BUTTERSCOTCH PEG BAGS

$3.49

Quick View

REED'S CINNAMON PEG BAGS

$3.49

Quick View

REED'S ROOT BEER PEG BAGS

$3.49

Quick View

CHERRY LOADERS - Medium Bags

$47.88

Quick View

JOLLY RANCHERS FREEZE DRIED CANDY

$6.99

Sold
out
Quick View

ICELANDIC SIRIUS 33% MILK CHOCOLATE TOFFEE BAR

$6.99

Quick View

DUBAI CHOCOLATE BAR

$14.99

Sold
out
Quick View

MIKE and IKE COTTON CANDY THEATER BOX

$1.95

Quick View

MIKE and IKE ROOT BEER FLOAT THEATER BOX

$1.95

Quick View

PEELERZ GUMMY ORANGE

From $3.99

Quick View

PEELERZ GUMMY LEMON

From $3.99

Quick View

TOXIC WASTE SLIME LICKER 2.0 GREEN APPLE & BLACK CHERRY

From $3.99