This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Free Shipping on Orders Greater than $75!*

Heat sensitive items may require expedited shipping at an additional cost.

The Penny Candy Store The Penny Candy Store

Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

New Items

Home/Collections/New Items
Quick View

PUMPKIN PEEPS 3 PK

$1.50

Quick View

MINI MINI CHOCOLATE

From $1.49

Quick View

FORT KNOX GOLD MILK CHOCOLATE INGOTS

From $2.49

Quick View

CHOCOLATE TOOTSIE POPS

$21.00

Quick View

NEAPOLITAN COCONUT BAR

$1.99

Quick View

DIP-N-LIK ROLLER BALL

From $1.99

Quick View

RING POP GUMMIES

$25.00

Quick View

SUPER GUMMY FROG

$4.99

Quick View

JUICY DROP GUMMY DIP 'N STICK

From $2.99

Quick View

FRUITY PEBBLES CANDY BAR

From $2.49

Quick View

SOUR PUNCH FAN FAVORITES BITES

$2.29

Quick View

SOUR PUNCH TROPICAL BLENDS BITES

$2.29

Quick View

SOUR PUNCH STRAWBERRY BITES

$2.29

Quick View

SOUR PUNCH BLUE RASPBERRY BITES

$2.29

Quick View

REESE'S DIPPED PRETZELS

$3.49

Sold
out
Quick View

STARBURST SWIRLERS

From $3.25