This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Free Shipping on Retail Orders Greater than $125!*

Heat sensitive items require expedited shipping fees.

The Penny Candy Store The Penny Candy Store

Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

Products

Home/Collections/All Products
Sold
out
Quick View

PEEPS MARSHMALLOW - BLUE

$1.99

Sold
out
Quick View

PEEPS MARSHMALLOW - YELLOW

$1.99

Quick View

PENNY CANDY FRUITS

From $2.50

Quick View

PENNY CANDY FRUITS (RUNTS REPLACEMENT)

$37.50

Quick View

PENNY CANDY SUPER MIX HARD CANDY

$18.00

Quick View

PEPPERMINT BALLS HARD CANDY

From $6.40

Quick View

PEPPERMINT BARK

$12.00

Quick View

PEPPERMINT STARLIGHTS

From $6.40

Quick View

PERCY PIG GUMMY CANDY

$15.00

Quick View

PEZ CANDY & DISPENSER - DISNEY PIXAR LIGHTYEAR

$2.19

Quick View

PEZ CANDY & DISPENSER - MARVEL AVENGERS SERIES

$2.19

Quick View

PEZ CANDY & DISPENSER - SCOOBY-DOO! CHARACTERS

$2.19

Quick View

PEZ CANDY & DISPENSER - SPACE JAM A NEW LEGACY

$2.19

Quick View

PEZ REFILL 6-PACK ASSORTED FLAVORS

From $2.50

Quick View

PEZ REFILLS ASSORTED 12oz BAG

$6.89

Quick View

PINK AND BLUE BUBBLE GUM GUMMI BERRIES

From $6.40