This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Free Shipping on Retail Orders Greater than $75!*

Heat sensitive items require expedited shipping fees.

The Penny Candy Store The Penny Candy Store

Shopping Cart

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

Products

Reset - 67 products shown
Home/Collections/All Products
Quick View

PINK GUMMI BERRIES - STRAWBERRY

From $6.40

Quick View

ROCK CANDY - BRIGHT PINK

$1.25

Quick View

ROCK-PAPER-SCISSORS

From $1.99

Quick View

ROSES PINK

From $2.79

Quick View

SNEAKY STARDUST

From $1.99

Quick View

SOUR LACES STRAWBERRY

From $2.50

Quick View

SOUR OOZE TUBE

From $1.99

Quick View

SOUR PATCH WATERMELON

From $2.50

Quick View

SOUR STRAWS PINK LEMONADE

$6.40

Quick View

STARBURST ALL PINK

From $1.99

Sold
out
Quick View

STARBURST ALL PINK

From $6.40

Sold
out
Quick View

STRAWBERRY CAKE GUMMI CANDY

From $6.00

Quick View

SWEET SOAKER

From $1.99

Quick View

SWINGIN' SLOTH TOY

From $1.99

Quick View

UNICORN DOO

From $1.99

Quick View

VALENTINE'S DAY FORT KNOX MILK CHOCOLATE MEDALLIONS

$3.99